Audit Procedures for Employee Benefits: Risks, Assertion, and Procedures

Employee benefits are a type of liability that a company incurs in exchange for services provided by its employees. These benefits can take many forms, including pensions, medical insurance, paid time off, and severance packages.

The accounting treatment for employee benefits requires companies to recognize the cost of these benefits as they are earned, typically over the period of time that the employees work for the company.

This is typically done through accrual accounting, where the company sets aside funds to pay for these benefits in the future.

Audit Risks:

  1. Misrepresentation of employee benefit plans: Companies may falsely represent the terms and conditions of employee benefit plans, leading to incorrect recognition of liabilities.
  2. Improper recognition of liabilities: Companies may improperly recognize liabilities related to employee benefits, leading to over- or under-stated obligations.
  3. Unfunded liabilities: Companies may not set aside enough funds to cover the costs of employee benefits, leading to unfunded liabilities.
  4. Inaccurate measurement of actuarial assumptions: Companies may make incorrect assumptions about the future costs of employee benefits, leading to incorrect liability recognition.
  5. Lack of proper internal controls: Companies may have weak internal controls over employee benefit plans, making it easier for inaccuracies to occur.
  6. Inadequate disclosure: Companies may not fully disclose information about their employee benefit plans, leading to a lack of transparency.
  7. Mismanagement of employee benefit plans: Companies may mismanage employee benefit plans, leading to inaccurate financial reporting.
  8. Miscommunication with employees: Companies may miscommunicate with employees about their benefits, leading to misunderstandings and incorrect reporting.
  9. Improper administration of employee benefit plans: Companies may improperly administer employee benefit plans, leading to incorrect recognition of liabilities.
  10. Changes in laws and regulations: Changes in laws and regulations regarding employee benefits can lead to incorrect financial reporting.
See also  What are Key Audit Matters? (Definition, Explanation, and More)

Audit Assertions:

The audit assertions for employee benefits include the following:

  1. Existence: The existence of employee benefits obligations must be confirmed.
  2. Completeness: All employee benefit obligations must be recorded in the financial statements.
  3. Accuracy: The amounts recorded for employee benefit obligations must be accurate.
  4. Valuation: Employee benefit obligations must be valued at their present value.
  5. Classification: Employee benefit obligations must be classified correctly in the financial statements.

Walkthrough Testing:

In walkthrough testing, the auditor performs a top-down analysis of the process for recognizing and reporting employee benefits. The auditor begins by reviewing the company’s policies and procedures related to employee benefits and then walks through the steps involved in recognizing and reporting these benefits.

The auditor also considers the control environment, including internal controls, and identifies any potential risks.

Test of Control:

In a test of control, the auditor evaluates the effectiveness of the company’s internal controls over the recognition and reporting of employee benefits.

This includes testing the control activities related to employee benefit plans, such as authorizations, approvals, and recordkeeping. The auditor also evaluates the accuracy of the data input into the accounting systems and the accuracy of the financial reports.

Substantive Audit Procedures:

Substantive audit procedures are the key techniques used by auditors to obtain sufficient and appropriate audit evidence to support their opinion on the financial statements.

In the context of employee benefits, substantive audit procedures should be designed to address the following audit risks:

  1. Misstatement of Employee Benefit Liabilities: This risk is related to the potential for incorrect measurement and recognition of employee benefit liabilities. Auditors should perform procedures to verify the accuracy of employee benefit liability calculations, including the calculation of actuarial assumptions and the discount rate used to measure the liability.
  2. Misstatement of Employee Benefit Expense: This risk relates to the potential for incorrect measurement and recognition of employee benefit expense. Auditors should perform procedures to verify the accuracy of the expense calculation, including the calculation of service cost, interest cost, and expected return on plan assets.
  3. Misstatement of Employee Benefit Plan Assets: This risk relates to the potential for incorrect measurement and recognition of employee benefit plan assets. Auditors should perform procedures to verify the accuracy of the plan asset calculations, including the calculation of fair value and the determination of the market value of the plan assets.
  4. Misstatement of Employee Benefit Plan Contributions: This risk relates to the potential for incorrect measurement and recognition of employee benefit plan contributions. Auditors should perform procedures to verify the accuracy of the contribution calculations, including the calculation of employer contributions, employee contributions, and contributions from other sources.
  5. Misstatement of Employee Benefit Plan Distributions: This risk relates to the potential for incorrect measurement and recognition of employee benefit plan distributions. Auditors should perform procedures to verify the accuracy of the distribution calculations, including the calculation of benefits paid to plan participants and the calculation of benefit payments made to beneficiaries.
  6. Inadequate Plan Disclosures: This risk relates to the potential for insufficient disclosure of employee benefit plans. Auditors should review the disclosure notes included in the financial statements to ensure that they are complete, accurate, and comply with relevant accounting standards.
  7. Misapplication of Employee Benefit Accounting Standards: This risk relates to the potential for incorrect application of accounting standards for employee benefits. Auditors should perform procedures to ensure that the company is applying relevant accounting standards consistently and correctly.
See also  What Are the Audit Processes? 7 Key Processes You Should Know

In addition to the substantive audit procedures outlined above, auditors should also consider using substantive analytical procedures and sample-based tests to obtain evidence to support their audit opinion.

These procedures should be designed to address the specific audit risks identified in the audit plan and to provide reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free from material misstatements.

Scroll to Top